The Orkney Symposium 
September 5-6-7, 1997 at Kirkwall, Orkney
By Pres. David and Gloria Bouschor


    September 5-6-7, 1997 saw the congregation of Sinclairs and others interested persons in Kirkwall Orkney.  They gathered to hear presentations on the Sinclair Voyage of 1398 to the New World.  The sessions were held at the Ayre Hotel and presided over by Josh Gourley.  Josh along with Niven Sinclair set up the symposium.  The large rubbing of the Westford Knight brooded over the proceedings to remind us what the Voyage left in Westford.  The presentations were most thought provoking both pro and con.  A jury had been provided to determine whether the voyage took place, on the basis of what they heard.  The proof standard was "beyond a reasonable doubt".  This standard of proof, unfortunately chosen, is the highest standard possible in the legal system.  It is used in criminal proceedings.  The jury not unexpectedly returned the unique Scottish Verdict of "Not Proven".  This may have been the proper verdict for a legal proceeding, but the 600-old evidences and coincidences ar3e too great to deny the voyage ever happened.  The Mi'kmaq Indians were present and made a presentation that was most impressive.  They do not take a stand one way or another.  They have an ideographic written language that is strikingly similar to Egyptian Hieroglyphics.  They identified Masonic Symbols on the "Kirkwall Scroll" as being used by them to denote deity and other attributes of their society.  Upon presenting a flag of the Mi'kmaq Nation to Niven Sinclair at a dinner in Roslin, the Templar Historian John Richie remarked that the flag was a replica of the Templar Fleet Battle Flag.  It is a great banner with a large red cross, like the cross of St. George, and in two of it's quadrants contain a red crescent and a red sword.  The Mi'kmaq oral tradition tells of a white man with a beard that gave this to them.  Interesting!

The Symposium was well attended by Sinclairs as well as locals.  Josh Gourley planned a visit to Kirkwall Lodge #39 to let us view the famed "Kirkwall Scroll".  It came to the lodge in 1789 and was identified as a floor cloth for degree work.  Kirkwall Lodge was chartered by the Grand Lodge of Scotland in 1736, and it's Charter was signed by William St. Clair of Rosslyn as it's first Grand Master.  The Lodge also has a Conclave of the Red Cross of Constantine.  It is the St. Clare Conclave.  The local City Council held a reception for those attending and were most cordial and hospitable.  The Symposium was not only an excellent endeavor but was a marvelous social experience.  The people of Orkney are most hospitable.  On Saturday Evening we attended a Ceilidh and some joined in with the local in country dancing.  We also shared their excellent locally distilled single malt, "Highland Park".

Our gracious host throughout was Niven Sinclair.  He provided bus transportation which was second to none in the touring of the Island (Orkney).  Our first night in Caithness we stayed in Niven's home town, Lybster.  The next day we proceeded to Scrabster for the ferry to Orkney.  James Whittal, one of the presenters from Massachusetts, and an archeologist, took us for a bus tour around the Island of Kirkwall to Scara Brae, Maeshowe Cairn, Ring of Brognar, and Church of St. Ophir.  Our bus driver, never having been in Orkney, was masterful at negotiating the narrow roads.  On Sunday many of us attended church at St. Magnus Cathedral.  It is now a Church of Scotland.  The church founded in 1113 contains the bones of St. Magnus and St. Rognwald.  There are also many Sinclairs buried in the church.  An old Templar tombstone in the church contains the effigy of a sword with a hilt similar to that of the Westford Knight.  Another coincidence!

Those who attended this marvelous event owe a great deal of thanks to Niven Sinclair who was the source of this fine program.  All of us came away from the presentation more convinced than ever that "Jarl HENRY DID IT".

========================================================
SUMMARY OF THE ORKNEY SYMPOSIUM 1997
H.S."Pete" Cummings, Jr.--
Genealogist for Clan Sinclair USA at the time

A panel of seventeen experts in various phases of Henry Sinclair and his 1398 Voyage to North America made a 1-hour presentation on specific subjects.  See the summaries which follow.  All told, they conveyed an impressive body of information about this Earl of Orkney.

The Times Were Ready!  Dr. Peter Waddell, Univ. of Strathclyde, author and inventor, told of the Hanseatic League from northern Germany during the 14th 15th centuries.   They monopolized trade between the Baltic seaports.  The Danish & Norwegian kings became deeply in debt to the Hansea.  Queen Margaret of Norway & Denmark sought to develop a "Northern Commonwealth" to compete.  Meanwhile, the Venetian trading ships were venturing into the Baltic waters.  This was the time when Jarl Henry Sinclair was granted the earldom of Orkney.  Nicolo Zeno from Venice is known to have been employed by Henry Sinclair.

Sinclair's Castle in Orkney Dr. Peter D. Anderson, the Deputy Keeper of the Records, described the Sinclair dynasty and its fortress.  While no visible trace of Kirkwall Castle remains today, ancient records and pictures tell us that it was located on the shore of the harbor in Kirkwall, in the vicinity of the present Broad & Castle Streets.  The Castle was rectangular, surrounded by a larger curtain wall 55 ft. long by 11 ft. thick.  Built in 1380's by Jarl Henry, it served the earldom until about 1470.  It's final days were during the Battle of Somersdale which was fought by two competing branches of the Sinclair family, fighting over control of portions of Orkney, Shetland, & Caithness.  (Memorial Stone marks the place today)

The Knights Templar Dr. Tim Wallace-Murphy, Templar Historian and author, spoke on the history, beliefs, & survival of the Knights Templar.  He noted that Sinclairs are woven within the Templar web.  Founded in Jerusalem in 1118 to guard the Christian pilgrimages, the Knights are believed to have found enormous treasure in the hidden vaults under the ancient Herod's Temple where they were quartered.  In addition, they found the secrets of "sacred geometry".  Membership rapidly grew and land was donated to them, forming a network stretching from the Holy Land to the far reaches of Europe.  Using their power base wisely, they became the leading money brokers in the world.  They built churches, fortifications, bridges and castles, while operating the largest fleet the world had ever seen.  
Moreover, they lent vast sums to popes, princes, kings and merchants.  King Philip le Bel of France devised a simple method to cancel his enormous debt, and that was the Suppression Order.  On Friday the 13th October 1307, sixty senior Knights were arrested in Paris.  Torture and death followed.  Most Templars fled safely to Lombardy, Scotland, Portugal and the Baltic states.  Those finding refuge in Scotland, fought as allies of Robert the Bruce and gained royal protection.  All documentary evidence was suppressed, except for their symbolism and architecture.  Rosslyn Chapel is a veritable encyclopedia in stone of Templar beliefs.

The Venetian Connection Dr. Andrew Sinclair, historian and author, presented some ways that Venice was evidenced in Jarl Henry's expedition.  There is today a large Zeno villa at Canareggio in Venice. Documents by Marco Barbaro entitled, "Libro di nozzi", reveal that Nicolo, the younger brother of Admiral Carlo Zeno, was commander of the Zicni (or Zichmni) fleet between 1383 and 1388.  In 1397 it is known that Nicolo Zeno was banned from office in Venice.  Another brother, Antonio, remained with Zichmni for another 13 years, when he retired in 1400.  The name of Zichmni is translated to be Sinclair.  A cannon, found in Louisburg Harbor, is identical to one on display in Venice, made in the late 1300's; it was obsolete by the 1400's.  The Zeno Map, made by Antonio and Nicolo, remained in use by mariners fro 150 years because of its accuracy.


Shetland, a Point of Voyage Departure? Dr. Jonathan Wills, a writer & boatman, described the coastline and vantage points in Shetland.   He noted that a logical route from Orkney to the New World would lead Jarl Henry to the Shetland Islands.  It could serve as an excellent "jumping-off" place.  Several sheltered harbors were identified.  Nearby, a lookout peak would be a necessity.  Such a location was Vera Burton.  Furthermore, an aerial reconnaissance by Niven Sinclair and Jon Wills found a site very likely to have been Jarl Henry's "castle", sheltering him while on land.

The Voyage and the Vision by Mark Finnan, a Canadian writer and broadcaster, described the vision of Jarl Henry's voyage.  Certainly, early explorers such as St. Brendon and Tim Severen, had unusual inspiration and faith in order to undertake their voyages.  Paul Knutson's exploration in 1362 has led many people to believe he was responsible for the unique stones found in the Minnesota and Lake Superior regions.  For Jarl Henry there were the family legends of his Viking ancestors.  More recently, he listened to the fishermen who returned from the north Atlantic seas with tales of population and vegetation.  The Zeno Map is admittedly crude and even erroneous in certain areas.  It is possible that part of the history of the crossing was made up in the Zeno Narratives.  Nevertheless, much truth can be gleaned from these documents.  True or not, John Cabot's voyage on the "Matthew" 100 years later has been heralded by the Queen of England, radio, television, and film makers.  The Jarl Henry saga is richer by far, for it contains a quest for the Holy Grail.

In the steps of Jarl Henry   William F. Mann, author urban planner, lead the audience through a labyrinth of clues, deep within the forests of Nova Scotia.  He told his reasons for believing that Jarl Henry followed those paths 600 years ago.  Moral allegory and sacred geometry form a basis for Bill's theories.  B y identifying certain known locations, it is possible to lay out a map over vitally important locations.  The landing site, the smoking hills, the Money Pit, and the two islands where Oak trees exist.  These, and many more identifiers, have led to the discovery of an ancient camp site thought to have been Jarl Henry Sinclair's.

The Legends of the Mi'kmaqs  Dr. Peter Christmas, head of Micmac Cultural Association of Nova Scotia, was assisted by Don Julien, chief executive of the Confederacy of Mainland Micmacs, and Kerry Prosper, Chief of the Confederacy of Mainland Micmac Indians, gave the audience a clear view of the organization, beliefs, and feelings of the Native Americans who probably welcomed Jarl Henry and his explorers.  They found a number of Masonic symbols which were similar to theirs.  However, they feel that many questions as to the historical significance are left unanswered.  Dr. Christmas said that in Mi'kmaq oral tradition, a great white man with a beard had come from far away beyond recorded memory.

Newport Tower James P. Whittall, Jr., Archaeological director of the Early Sites Research Center, spoke on the studies and beliefs surrounding the round stone building in New port, RI.  It was constructed in the style of Norman Romanesk architecture inspired from the Holy Sepulcher in Jerusalem.  The unique style of the Newport Tower was further influenced by the Templars' round churches of Scandinavia.  Local building traditions from whence the builders came also influenced its style.  Determination of the date of original construction is usually based upon the study of features such as arches, window, niches, beam holes, key stones, mortar, and the orientation of openings.  Those found within the Newport Tower have been dated in the broad range of 1150-1400.  However, some specific features narrow the range to the late 1300's.

Is It Possible that Jarl Henry did not do it?  Brian Smith, Shetland Archivist, offered a flamboyant array of reasons he feels cast a shadow upon the claim that Jarl Henry Sinclair crossed the ocean to North America.  Among them are a 500-year delay in making claims; the lack of contemporaneous claims by Sinclairs or Templars; numerous errors found in the Zeno Narratives; "Zichmni" referred to in the Zeno Narratives is thought to be really the Duke of Surrand; Nicolo Zeno was a political prisoner in Venice from 1360-1400; and the Zeno Narratives never mentioned Orkney.   

The confusion seems to arise over Nicolo Zeno having been in prison.  Firstly, Niven Sinclair says that he has seen no evidence of this and, in any event, the names Nicolo, Carlo and Antonio cascade down through the generations to even today. 
Secondly, the evidence which he has seen from the Zen family tree in the Zeno Palace during his December 1999 trip there, clearly shows Nicolo as being one of the brothers who explored the lands beneath the "Polo Arctico".  This is conformed by Torfaeus, the Royal Danish Historian in his "Lives of the Zeno Brothers".  Evidence of their voyages is also shown on two enormous globes in the Museo Correr in Venice.  So the Nicolo Zeno in prison, was certainly someone else in this large family.

Furthermore, the Zeno Narrative was also signed by the Venetian State Secretary, Ramusio, which effectively gave it the seal of approval of the Doge and the Council of Ten who governed Venetian affairs.  They would not have willingly, Knowingly or deliberately have debased the accurate historical records of the Venetian State by endorsing a forgery.  Venetian records are renowned for their accuracy.     See further proofs and account of    Niven's 1999 trip to Venice


Proofs that the voyage occurred  Niven Sinclair, businessman, researcher, and inspirer, presented a comprehensive set of "Proofs".  These are the result of Niven's tireless efforts to re-trace Henry Sinclair's footsteps around the world.  Facts were derived from many reliable references.  Aspiring for greatness, Henry became a Baron in 1358, Ambassador to Copenhagen in 1363, Crusader in 1365, and Jarl of Orkney in 1379.  While serving as Ambassador, Henry had contact with Carlo Zeno, Ivar Bardsson, Paul Knutson, and of course, Queen Margaret, at which time his planning for the voyage began.  In 1392 he went to London to purchase some ships.  The "Proofs" are as follows:

 ZENO Map:  Having enlisted Nicolo Zeno as fleet commander several years earlier, four ships were dispatched by Henry to chart the northern seas during 1393-1395.  The Treaty of Kalmer was signed in 1397. 

  CONTINGENCY PLANS:  Ten years prior to this, Jarl Henry gave indication of his forthcoming voyage because he distributed much of his land; to his brother, John, he gave Pentland and Shetland, brother David received the lands of Aberdeen, and to his daughter Elizabeth, he directed that his lands in Norway would go to her if he died without a male heir.  


ACCURACY of ZENO Map:  For the next several centuries, the Zeno Map was used by mariners and recognized by such well-known cartographers as Ruscelli, Ortelius, and Cornielle.  Professor Hapgood found 37 points of identity between the Zeno Map and recent aerial surveys by the US Air Force.

 
 ZENO NARRATIVE:  Many references in the Narrative could not have been fabricated by a writer two centuries later.  These include the Spring of Pitch and name references to places.  


14th CENTURY Cannon: Found in the waters of Louisburg Harbor, this cannon is exactly the same as one on display in Venice, which is authenticated to be late 14th century in origin. 


 NEWPORT TOWER:  Many features in this Tower provide good evidence, though contested, that it was built by the Sinclair expedition.  


LEGENDS OF THE MICMACS:  There are many clues in the oral history of the Native Americans which indicate the influence of Henry Sinclair in their land.  


WESTFORD KNIGHT CARVING: Located in Westford, MA there is a stone ledge onto which is carved a full-sized armorial effigy of a 14th century knight holding a shield bearing the crest of Clan Gunn. 


 BOAT STONE: An egg-shaped rock measuring about 18" in diameter was found in Westford, MA bearing a carved impression of a 14th century ship and the numerals "184" with an arrow.  


SCOTTISH EVIDENCE IN ROSLYN CHAPEL:  Carved in stone about 1450 there are some aloe and some corn, both believed to have been unknown in Europe at the time, unless they were transported back from America by Jarl Henry

Contact the Web Developer, Bryan Ginn
www.clansinclairusa.org